Skip to content
Mother and young daughter talking in the kitchen

What Is “Backtalk” and How Do I Handle It?

Why your child’s pushback isn’t always disrespectful and how to respond without getting pulled into a power struggle.

In This Post

  • Not every disagreement is disrespect.
  • Our ability to regulate our own emotions is one of the most important tools we have when navigating challenging behavior.
  • You can allow the feeling while still holding the boundary.

If you’re a parent, chances are you’ve experienced this scenario. You ask your child to do something relatively simple, like put their shoes on, turn off the TV, or clean up their toys, and you’re met with an immediate response.

“Why do I have to?” “You’re so mean!” “No! I’m not doing that!”

And just like that, you’re in a power struggle.

For many parents, these moments can feel incredibly triggering. You might find yourself thinking, Who do they think they’re talking to?

Or maybe you hear yourself saying something your own parents said to you: “Don’t you talk back to me!”

But what if we looked at backtalk a little differently?

What Is Backtalk, Really?

Backtalk is typically described as a child responding to an adult in a way that is argumentative, defiant, or disrespectful. But here’s where I think we need to be careful.

Not every disagreement is disrespect.

Sometimes what we label as backtalk is simply a child expressing frustration, disappointment, or a desire for more independence. Children are learning how to navigate their emotions, communicate their needs, and develop a sense of autonomy.

And that process isn’t always going to look or sound pretty.

This doesn’t mean we ignore unkind words or allow our children to speak to us however they want. It means we recognize that teaching respectful communication is very different from demanding unquestioning obedience.

Why Backtalk Can Be So Triggering

For many of us, disagreement wasn’t welcomed when we were growing up. We may have learned that being a “good kid” meant listening to adults, following directions, and not questioning authority.

So when our children push back, we can interpret their words as a challenge to our authority.

We raise our voices, threaten consequences, or start arguing. And suddenly, we’re participating in the very behavior we’re trying to stop.

This is why I remind parents that our ability to regulate our own emotions is one of the most important tools we have when navigating challenging behavior.

How to Respond When Your Child Talks Back

1. Don’t Take the Bait

The first thing I encourage parents to do is to not take the bait.

Let’s say you tell your child it’s time to turn off the television, and they respond, “You’re the worst mom ever!” Your instinct might be to immediately address the comment. But now the conversation has shifted from holding a boundary to arguing about what your child said.

Try Saying

Instead, try saying, “I know you’re upset. It’s hard to stop when you’re having fun. The TV is still going off.”

That’s it. You don’t need to convince your child that your decision is fair. You don’t need them to agree with you. You just need to hold the boundary.

2. Allow the Feeling, Hold the Boundary

The next thing to remember is that you can allow the feeling while still holding the boundary.

Two things can be true at the same time. Your child can be upset about a boundary, and that boundary can still stand.

Try Saying

If your child refuses to clean up their toys, you might say, “I hear you. You don’t feel like cleaning up right now. The toys still need to be put away before dinner. Would you like to start with the blocks or the cars?”

You’re acknowledging the feeling without changing the expectation, while offering some autonomy within the boundary. Your child’s feelings don’t have to change in order for you to hold a boundary.

3. Teach the Skill Outside the Moment

Finally, teach the skill outside the moment. When children are frustrated or overwhelmed, they’re not necessarily in a place to process a lengthy lesson about respect. Save the teaching for later.

Try Saying

You might say, “Earlier, you were really frustrated when I asked you to turn off the TV. It’s okay to be upset with me, but calling someone names isn’t okay. Next time, you can tell me, ‘I’m frustrated. I wish I could watch longer.’”

We’re not teaching children to suppress their feelings. We’re teaching them how to express those feelings respectfully. And remember, learning new skills takes practice and repetition.

Team Supercrew books to help start the conversation about big feelings

Books to Help Start the Conversation

Emotions and Powers 4 Book Box Set, $39.99

Start Reading

The Bigger Picture

Most of us want to raise children who are confident, independent thinkers. We want them to advocate for themselves, set boundaries, and feel comfortable expressing their opinions.

But those skills don’t suddenly appear in adulthood. They begin developing in childhood, often through the very moments we find challenging.

The next time your child talks back, see if you can pause before reacting. Ask yourself, Is my child being disrespectful, or are they expressing something they haven’t yet learned how to communicate effectively?

Sometimes it’s a little of both.

Either way, we have an opportunity to teach our children that their voice matters, their feelings are valid, and boundaries still exist.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I teach my child to respectfully disagree with adults?

Start by helping your child understand that disagreement isn’t disrespectful. Children are allowed to feel frustrated, disappointed, or unhappy with a decision. What we want to teach them is how to communicate those feelings respectfully.

One of the best ways to do this is by giving them language they can use in those moments. Instead of saying, “You’re so mean!” or “I hate you!” teach them to say things like, “I wish your answer were different,” “I’m really not happy about this,” or “I’m frustrated because I wanted more time.”

These phrases allow children to express their feelings without using hurtful language. Remember, the goal isn’t to raise children who always agree with us. It’s to raise children who know how to use their voice respectfully, even when they’re upset.

Should I give my child a consequence for talking back?

Not every instance of backtalk requires a consequence. Often, a calm boundary and an opportunity to practice more respectful language are more effective than punishment.

Before responding, consider what’s happening beneath the behavior. Is your child overwhelmed, frustrated, or struggling to communicate? The goal is to teach the skill your child is missing, rather than simply make the behavior stop.

Team Supercrew SOS Kit: super tools for super big feelings

Super Tools for Super Big Feelings

Empower your child with the skills they need to regulate their emotions! Team Supercrew SOS Kit, $44.99

Shop the SOS Kit

Albiona Rakipi is a parenting coach, pediatric speech-language pathologist, and early childhood development expert with over 20 years of experience supporting children and families. She is the founder of The Parenting Reframe and creator of the PARR Method, helping parents regulate their emotions, navigate challenging behaviors, and build stronger connections with their children.

Leave a comment